Regardless if you hated him or not I’d have to go with JT. Man had fighting experience so he would probably take everyone in fair dig. Andrew Collura, Big Richard and Brad could possibly hold their own aswell. Big Lenny, Jason, Ian McCarthy would be bottom 3.
JT is the only one who had experience. Brad maybe know how to throw down. Gahlic knots could probably slap a guy and not flinch. Everyone else would melt in any confrontation.